Cesspool of Antagonists

a conversation with Bri Chapman


As an editor, there’s always a bit of trepidation that accompanies receiving a submission from someone you care about. Our standards at Chatterbox! are high, and, until recently, the only writing of Bri’s I’d read was her (excellent) poetry. So, upon seeing Bri’s submission in our queue, I felt nervous at the prospect of having to reject a close friend. I shouldn’t have worried. “Amy’s Chinese Boyfriend” is thoughtful, precise, and beautifully written. Bri approaches fraught, timely topics with care, nuance, and directness. 

Bri Chapman and I met over Zoom to discuss the story. Bri did the interview in her parents’ bedroom where, apparently, the WiFi signal in her house was the strongest. Above her head, there was a wall decoration that read “GIVE IT TO GOD…AND GO TO SLEEP.” Below is a transcript of that conversation which has been heavily edited to omit (some of) our random asides, references to our personal lives, and inside jokes that would make no sense out of context. If nothing else, I hope this interview challenges you to think a little more critically about the content you consume. 

Kara Crawford: Starting broad, why did you want to write about K-pop and its fan culture?

Bri Chapman: Okay, this is a long answer. There's a scene in the story that is extremely auto-fictional. I was just scrolling on my YouTube, probably 15 years old, on our family computer, and I came across the “Blood Sweat & Tears” music video. It wasn’t like anything I’d ever seen before, I probably watched it dozens of time in the family computer room. This was right before they had caught fire in the US, which I would argue happened more in like 2018 to 2020, when BTS was coming out with Butter and Dynamite, a lot of their mainly-English songs. This would have been Wings era BTS.

But it just got me, it so got me, and I was like 16 begging my mom to buy me K-Pop albums. We would play BTS CDs in the car. I still have all my BTS K-pop albums...one time I did bring one to school. At home, nobody knew what I was talking about (mostly), so it was a comfortable place for me to be weird about it, to be really weird about, like, Suga from BTS. I was telling my mom everything about him. Sorry, mom. 

And then I went to college and I realized to some degree that was embarrassing, especially when making international friends. They'd be like, “What kind of music do you listen to?” and I didn't know why, but I would feel super ashamed and embarrassed to talk about it because people would start giving me looks. I didn't really know what the looks meant, but I knew to stop talking. I developed a more casual relationship with the music.

Then I moved back home again after grad school, which is where the answer starts. Being unemployed, I just felt myself getting sucked really intensely back in. SHINee just had a comeback earlier this year and they are my favorite group. Taemin had his big moment at Coachella which brought him into a Western audience, which was really crazy because SM groups, in particular SHINee, are more in the bubble of East Asian tours and East Asian promotion, I think intentionally.

KC: Sorry, for the uninitiated, could you explain what SM is? 

BC: They are the company SHINee is under. SM Entertainment is one of the big three companies that put groups together, kind of like Simon Cowell did with One Direction. SM is huge. They put together TVXQ and EXO and SHINee and NCT and Girls Generation, and, you know, they've been that girl. They are also evil. 

Clearly I’ve kind of started falling down the parasocial hole again. It's all built to be parasocial. The companies want you to engage with idol groups in this really strange, hyper-personal yet hyper-corporate and sanitized way. They want you to feel super close to these members, and they do everything so that happens. It’s a deeply emotional experience? You start to feel real feelings—pride and happiness and sometimes devastation—for people you don’t know. 

Again, I had a lot of time to think about this, the way I interacted with K-pop as a teenager. 

I was having a conversation with a friend about how white people are often very hesitant to write about their own racism and the microaggressions that happen behind closed doors. And that when I was 16 and I was interacting with K-pop groups, it was in a hyper-fetishistic, micro-aggressive way. It just was. I am lucky to have met people who checked me and who would ask me questions about the things that I would say and do, and who cared enough to tell me that I was being inappropriate. 

But I was wondering about people who that either doesn't happen for, or who don't care, or those who enjoy the willful ignorance of interacting with K-pop and with Korean media and Korean culture in a way that is just taking and taking and taking without learning. K-pop is a hyper capitalistic industry that will allow you to just like, endlessly consume. 

I wanted to write something about a person who wanted to live in willful ignorance, but who also genuinely loves this group and their music. 

KC: That makes sense. I think my next question follows this nicely. This story contends with the really messy boundaries between desire/appreciation and fetishization. We have a white narrator who's obsessed with a K-pop star and is also, as we’ve already talked about, very oblivious of her own racism towards East Asian men. As a white woman writer yourself, could you talk about the challenges of trying to write a character like Amy, and the challenges of writing a story that explores racial fetishization?

BC: Amy is not autofictional, but unfortunately she was not very difficult for me to write because I was this person for a very long time. I was her, but younger than she is in this story. She's 16-year-old me with an MBA and access to money. I spent a lot of time being—and I still am—quite ashamed of the way that I interacted with K-pop and Korean culture and East Asian culture in general when I was a teenager.

But I think the challenge is to not make her into a super villain. The things that Amy does are wrong and they're bad and they're gross and they're really uncomfortable and she should be ashamed of herself—but she isn't. Truly, I do not think Amy is the kind of person who will ever deconstruct the way that she interacts with the world. I think my difficulty was balancing her doing things that were wrong and bad and gross while also keeping her very human. And, to some degree, sympathetic. That was challenging. 

KC: Yeah, to adequately point out where she falls short, you have to actually understand the character on a human level, which you can't do if she is like the cardboard cut out of a villain. 

BC: Yeah, yeah. If she were running around with—I say this lovingly—with a misspelled Korean language tattoo and the cheaply-made—I had one of these that's why I'm saying it—the cheaply printed Amazon fan t-shirt, if she were trying to drop Korean language into conversations, if she’s acting like a standard Koreaboo, that wouldn’t work. That's not who this person is, how her microaggressions surface. 

The challenge of Amy is making her believable and sympathetic while also writing the ways in which she is inappropriately interacting with the world around her, and showing that her ignorance is not stupidity. She’s been allowed to grow up without having to confront her beliefs and behavior. I think that's something that Jess [another Chatterbox! editor] and I talked a lot about when we were doing the developmental edits, is that in the first draft, there were points where Amy just comes off as being stupid. And Amy isn't stupid. She is just so in her own bubble of privilege where she is allowed, as a white woman, to just consume to the point where she projects her aesthetic desire onto ANY East Asian man. In this case it’s Henry, who does have a name that she never used. 

KC: I've got some questions locked and loaded about that one.

BC: She uses Henry to fulfill her fantasies. It's not about his culture, it's not about him. Amy is consuming him as if he is a photo card that she can tout around on her phone and show off to the ladies at work. 

Similarly, I don't want the story itself to fetishize Henry, I don't want him to be a plot-device for Amy to “learn through” that the reader also just consumes and then puts away. Toeing that line was really difficult because I was always worried I was going to make a mistake and not be able to see it, like Amy, so I was very concerned about that while I was writing the story—the handling of him as a person. I didn't want to just make him a good, beautiful, awesome, perfect guy who is entirely a victim because that in itself is a sort of fetishization. And so I created him as a real complicated person who is also, in many ways, victimized by Amy's ignorance, but is not ignorant to that victimization. He's not an idiot; he's not unaware. 

KC: Where do you see someone like Amy in the K-pop fandom? Is she meant to be representative of a larger problem? I’m sure you’re going to say yes, but let’s talk about this.

BC: My experience is being a white K-pop fan, so I'm gonna mostly talk about other white K-pop fans. And in that sense, yes, a lot of it is pure Orientalism. A lot of companies are trying to get their groups to bridge into Westernization. Groups like BTS and Blackpink, for example. Like I said, Taemin just performed at Coachella; BIGBANG, which is a second-gen group, they're OG. Do you know who BIGBANG is?

KC: No, but I don’t know much aside from what I’ve learned from you and Jess. 

BC: They had a viral song, Fantastic Baby, in the 2010s. [sings the hook]

KC: I think I remember that soundbyte. 

BC: So, there were viral moments that happened. They would appear on KIDS REACT and those kinds of YouTube channels where the setup is that we, the viewer, are looking at this and going, “Whoa look how weird and foreign that is” and then putting it away. There's a GOT7 music video where they're all really small (“Just Right”). And I think because it was so “strange,” it went viral and then got put away. Though I imagine the same way that when I saw “Blood Sweat & Tears,” there were people who watched and went, “Wow, I've never seen anything like this” and connected to it, but they certainly didn’t go mainstream in the US way that “Dynamite” did. 

Now we’re hearing K-pop in Food Lion and you can buy K-pop albums on Amazon. So, in that sense, the way that we consume K-pop shifts because now it's not just a spectacle. You can attach yourself to your favorite member and access to the music is much easier, and then you don't see where that has any direct impact on you except for pleasure. The companies want to make money more than anything, so there is a benefit for them, too, for the mindless consumerism, the buy, buy, buy, the stan, stan, stan, the love, love, love. Eventually that penetrates into broader culture—when I was talking to my partner about this, he was like, the only thing I know about K-pop is #StanJungkook. 

KC: This is more recent but I’ve seen high schoolers online being like, “I'm staying home from school today and calling in sick so that I can stream the new song to get the numbers up.”

BC: Oh, yeah. I asked my mom one time if I could do that. And she was like, “What? Are you crazy?” She was like, “Absolutely not. No, that's not happening. You're going to get your ass on that bus and you're going to go to school.” My mom is such an interesting player in this because she is supportive but confused. She does not know the difference between SHINee and BTS.

KC: Not to call out your mother—lovely woman—but do you think that if you were obsessed with Western boy bands, it would be the same? Would she be confused in the same way and unable to tell the difference between, say, One Direction and 5 Seconds of Summer? Or is the foreignness part of the confusion?  

BC: To my mom, and I think probably to a lot of passive listeners, it all sounds the same because it's in a language that you don't understand and aren't curious about. Sometimes I drive her to work and I’ll play SHINee and she always thinks they’re BTS. It’s just not her thing—it’s radio pop music treatment. Taemin is Ten, Niall is Harry, the song plays and it’s got a good beat and then it’s over.  

Whereas, you get an Amy who has an intricate relationship with the group, but who doesn’t want to investigate the thing she’s consuming beyond what gives her pleasure. She doesn’t want to be uncomfortable with her consumption. She doesn’t want to think too hard about why she likes the music she likes or why she’s interacting with SEDAT(iv) the way she is.

Not all fans are like this—K-pop suffers from the same bad rap as other large cultural movements spearheaded by young women (re: Twilight). There are casual fans who just really like music, fans who love the dances. I have a friend that knows so much and has written incredible papers, genuine scholarship, on gender performance through clothing in K-pop and the way that's changed throughout the years. 

I think where there’s real criticism, where it becomes uncomfortable or not normal, is when fans don’t examine why and how we like the things that we like, why and how we buy the things that we buy.  

KC: We have to talk about Henry, Amy's “boyfriend.” I don't think we can do that without discussing the title of the story which is, of course, “Amy's Chinese Boyfriend.” Can you talk about your decision making process for naming this piece? And then, speaking of names, I'd like to talk about why you chose to leave Henry nameless for so much of the story.

BC: His race is being objectified, fetishized, and the title calls very direct and very clear attention to that. It’s shocking, I think, in the sense that if I saw that in a lit mag, I'd be like, “What the fuck?” But what she values about him are the “aesthetics” of his ethnicity. I chose the title because it lets you know from the get-go that this is a story about a white woman who does not just fetishize K-pop idols in the comfort of her own home, but who is taking that outside and who is making that her valuation system of other people.

KC: It's significant that Amy never calls Henry by his name, and that the first time we hear it is from Claire, very late in the story. Say more about that. 

BC: It was an intentional decision. There are a lot of drafts of the story, and this is something that has been consistent from draft one. Names are so important; names have a lot of weight, and taking that name away is an immediate motion toward dehumanization and objectification. He is positioned in the story, through Amy's perspective, as what he is to her and never who he is as his own person. The only moments of embodiment that you get are his own words. And, to some extent, his actions, but those are also being filtered through Amy's delusions. 

I also wanted there to be this moment when Claire does call him Henry that maybe you wonder if you were even curious about what his name was until it's said. Or do you fall so comfortably into the way that Amy views him that he becomes an object? Until Claire (who certainly has her own problems) says his name out loud.

KC: Totally. Henry is such a fascinating character because he is both a victim and a perpetrator of fetishization and cultural insensitivity. Why was it important that he be both? How did you work to strike that balance in the story?

BC: To reiterate, I didn't want to make him this perfect man who's never done anything wrong. First of all, because nobody like that would date Amy. She thinks that she's so covert but that shit's clockable. People who are fetishized are going to know that they're being fetishized, people who are objectified are going to figure out that they're being objectified. I think if Henry was entirely virtuous and ignorant to his dynamic with Amy, that would undercut the intention of the story. He would become infantilized.  Henry is a pleasure-seeker in the way that Amy is a pleasure-seeker. 

KC: And he seems to really be into white women. It’s on his For You page. His algorithm is the big titty blonde white lady thing. 

BC: Yeah, yeah. Like what I was saying earlier, when you're being fetishized, when you're being objectified, there is a moment where you realize. Henry certainly knows exactly what's happening. This man is like, “We are getting the same thing out of each other,” and he’s okay with that because he's not really her boyfriend. This is just some girl that he is having sex with that he'd like to continue having sex with. Yeah, I wanted there to be a moment in bed where her whiteness is called into being as something that is desirable to him, where she can't quite articulate her own discomfort. Even when Henry calls attention to the transactional elements of their dynamic, she refuses to engage with it. Amy does not like to deal with things.

KC: And what about his cultural appropriation?

BC: Henry (again, similar to Amy) enjoys consuming without much thought. Though  he comes from a vastly different cultural context than Amy, he similarly consumes Black artists in a way that generalizes and aestheticizes. 

In the story, though, I think that Henry’s cultural appropriation has much less to do with him and much more to do with pinpointing the way white people speak when they are the only ones in the room. Amy and Claire (especially Claire) are framed as the common, flavourless brand of “vaguely progressive” that many white women occupy. They know what is and is not “acceptable,” in the social situations and perhaps could articulate what are deemed to be appropriate talking points. However, proving their own morality to one another is much more important than speaking about Henry’s appropriation of Black culture. There’s a sense that Claire believes she is somehow holding Henry accountable, but how can this be possible when he isn’t even in the room? 

Through the mention of Ji-ho, I also wanted to acknowledge the ways Black culture is cycled into the corporate machine with the sole purpose of profit. This is especially prevalent in the K-pop industry. While that is not the central focus of the story, I think to ignore that aspect would have been a miss on my part. More recently, you have Mark Lee, an idol who wore a Confederate flag. Mark Lee, the Canadian, wears a Confederate flag, and then posts a disappearing apology on his Instagram Story. And then fans, some of the fans, forgive him and then everybody moves on—I’m sure by the time this comes out that reference will already feel outdated in the face of similar scandals.

KC: This story is also about the dissolution of a friendship. One of my favorite scenes is the one where Amy and Claire argue and try to out-woke each other. Can you talk about how that scene came to be?

BC: Thank you! In the first draft of this story, I actually intended Claire to be likeable. But then, in feedback I got, people were reading her in a much different way. Having worked so much on this story, I understand now, because if Clare is so morally superior to Amy, then what reason does she have to hang out with Amy aside from making herself feel superior? I had to consider what even makes them friends, because these are two very different people. Claire is this sort of strung out woman, and she seems to value the veneer of authenticity in a way that Amy just accepts is not true. Claire cares way more about how the idols are feeling, what kind of people they are, etc. With Amy, as much as she is willfully ignorant in her consumption, she knows that SEDAT(iv) are ultimately the product of a corporation. 

KC: Yes, she knows that if she were to meet Do-yun, he would not live up to what she wants from him, and we don't get that implication from Claire at all.

BC: Claire is thinking about how Davey feels, does Davey even want to be in the group anymore, would he be more successful making his own music, y’know, “I feel bad for him he's trapped.” She invests a lot of emotional energy toward a grown man who can and will make his own decisions about his career, believing she knows what’s “best.” And, ultimately, she doesn’t know him. That’s her brand of parasocialism—one that I think is relatable to fans of most anything, not just K-pop. I think this, alongside Claire’s tendency to purely occupy a  moral high ground, allows us to see two different kinds of fans. This “out-woking” conversation is where a lot of that tension comes to a head. 

KC: Yeah, this situation is just so crazy. I was very shocked when I read this version and I was so upset on Amy’s behalf. I don’t like this about myself because I certainly don’t want to be rooting for Amy, but I was distressed by Claire not bringing this up earlier. I felt so betrayed that Claire chose to use a photo from 2014 that Amy didn’t even know about as a gotcha, instead of telling Amy about it when she found it. 

BC: Claire, she does make it seem like she wants what's best for Amy. But really, she just likes that she feels more authentic. She feels more authentic in her love for this group. She feels more authentic in her attachment to Davey. And she feels superior because she has done—not all of the work—but some of the work. And because she has somebody who she can sort of separate herself from, like, maybe I used to be a fan like Amy, but now my authentic connection to the group makes me better (i.e., less microaggressive, less racist). She feels that she’s found herself in a position to pass judgement on others—on Amy, on Henry. She can privately shake her head at Amy, even though some of that moral superiority comes from Amy’s total ignorance of the situation.

KC: And that Claire actually looked him up on that app. Clearly she's seeking validation. 

BC: Yeah! And that also adds a layer, hopefully, of complication to Henry. Because this is a photograph that has been posted in 2014. It's not like he doesn't have an Instagram. It's not like he doesn't have a LinkedIn. He's aware enough to know that that photo should not be on those platforms, and he hasn't deleted it. And he hasn't deleted it from his Weibo. 

So Claire has finally got her ‘I told you so.’ From the beginning, she was trying to get Amy not to interact with this guy, she thinks he’s icky, but Amy decides to anyway. And Claire is like, “Fine, you're gonna learn your own lesson.” And then the minute that it falls apart, she's like, “Well, thank God.”

KC: But if she actually had either Henry's or Amy's best interests at heart, she would have gone about this entirely differently. 

BC: Absolutely. She doesn't care about Henry because she thinks he's a weird fuckboy. But with Amy, I think Claire sees this as a lesson learning moment, and Amy sees this as a deep and intense betrayal and so then shoots back. I also think the scene is kind of fun because you get to see Amy be more articulate. Amy is not unaware of how systems work, she just doesn't want to confront them because it messes with her comfort and pleasure. And the minute that that is disrupted within her friendship, she's like, “Okay, well, fuck you, at least I'm not a hypocrite.”

KC: I think that readers would be interested to know, like I do, that this story is actually part of a larger project. Can you tell me more about that? 

BC: Oh my god. Wait, that's such a nice question to ask. It’s going to be a linked story collection. I started writing “Amy’s Chinese Boyfriend” way earlier this year, and I had to think about this group so much. SEDAT(iv) needed proper lore so that when they come up in conversation on the page, it feels like two friends who really know what they're talking about. 

When I was finishing my first draft of this story, I was kind of in mourning because so much of that work felt left off the page. You really only get to see Do-yun, and, I was like, ‘Man that blows. I did all of this like background work and now nobody gets to see it.’ And one of my good friends, Katy, was like, “You can write more stories,” and I was like, “Whoa, that's crazy.” 

I wanted to continue exploring the themes of ACBF, to link my personal experiences with fandom and parasocialism. Really, this is a collection about the way that people mindlessly consume, with K-pop as the lens. Each story focuses on a fan with a different bias in the group. 

KC: I’m actually curious, now that we’re talking about it. Are all the main POV characters in these stories going to be white? 

BC: As it’s planned right now, all but one of them. They're also not all women! 

KC: Cool! Speaking of women, even though I knew you were writing a linked collection about K-pop, I don't think I realized that it was all going to be SEDAT(iv)-based. So, this question is not as relevant anymore, but I wonder how much the manuscript is going to feature or consider women idols. Could you talk about that? Do you have any interest in doing that at some point? 

BC: It’s definitely focused on male idols. I think part of that is “write what you know” or whatever. I just don't stan that many girl groups. I mean, I like AOA, I like Orange Caramel, I like Red Velvet, but I’ve never had that kind of deeply parasocial relationship with a girl group and I have a sense the fandoms function in different ways. It’s definitely something I’d like to do more research on, especially the particular flavour of misogyny that girl groups endure. 

KC: That makes sense. Okay, it's time for the fun question. If you could recommend one K-pop music video to readers, what would it be?

BC: What if I want to recommend more than one? Is that okay?

KC: What am I gonna do? I'm not gonna kill you if you give me two.

BC: What if I give you one girl group, one boy group? 

KC: Please do. Please give us some girl group representation.

[At this point, Bri thought for a long time. Kara went to the bathroom and returned.]

BC: Okay hi, thank you for being patient with me. I’m going to pitch ARTMS’s “Virtual Angel” and SHINee’s “Married to the Music.” 

KC: Well, those were my questions. It occurs to me that we didn't really talk about Do-yun specifically. I think that’s because I felt like his character was so supported by what was on the page that I didn’t have questions. Everything felt supported by the text. Do you know what I'm saying?

BC: I appreciate that, yeah. I think Jess said something that kind of summed the whole thing up to me, one time in passing. And she was like, “Well, the sympathetic character is Do-yun.” In some ways, he is the protagonist in a cesspool of antagonists. 

Next
Next

Amy's Chinese Boyfriend by Bri Chapman